Going back to history and using the University of Victoria site about Shakespeare as reference, we have found out that “in general, from the accession of Elizabeth to the reign of Charles I there was a revolution in education. The humanists and those who followed recognized and publicized the importance of education, with the result that schools became better funded, and better equipped.
There was a push by the Puritans for more funding for grammar schools in order to free education from social and financial barriers. With increased support (from the charity of various concerned groups in society, rather than from government), the grammar schools were able to educate more children from less wealthy families–Ben Jonson, one of the most learned men in the period, was the son of a bricklayer.”¹
However, they were boys who received education, not girls. According to the statistics, at least one third of the male population could read, though the proportion of literate women was certainly less–perhaps as low as one in ten.
Education for all children in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries depended on the financial standing and social class of the family. The main purpose of education was to teach children appropriate behaviour for their social class and to make them useful members of society.
Memorization and recitation constituted the main part of the teaching techniques. It was indispensable to become proficient in Latin, as it was the language of the educated throughout Europe. The curriculum was conservative, because most of the teachers had received their education in the old system, which concentrated on rhetoric.
Usually boys started to study in grammar school from the age of six or seven. The future after grammar school for most of them was apprenticeship: they found a master to whom they were bound as to a father; and the master, in turn, was responsible for the boy’s clothing, food, shelter and training. After seven years of apprenticeship, the boy could become a journeyman and work for salary. It was possible, however quite rare, for boys of poorer families to attend university through a scholarship or financing from a wealthy patron.
In other words, education was dependent on the social ranking of the person. Illiteracy was common to poor people; merchants, for example, were, of course, more educated than them. Most likely literate were the gentlemen because of the chance to attend education in the two best universities in England, the Cambridge University and Oxford University. There they were able to study theology, medicine, law, philosophy, and classical literature in both Greek and Latin.
Gentlemen’s sons were also given the opportunity to take up law studies in London’s Inns of Courts. The courts were to prepare them to become lawyers in the courts of law or in royal career services.
For further education and other learning possibilities besides university education, the nobility classes or the privileged ones were also provided with the opportunity to make tours around European major cities. That meant that they had to have financial solvency and, besides, a special license from the monarch.
As of the girls, as we read on the same site, “except among daughters of the nobility, and among the Puritans, formal schooling for girls was not encouraged. For those who were educated, subjects focused mainly on encouraging chastity and developing skills of housewifery.
A girl had to learn how to govern a household, and how to conduct herself in the social class into which her marriage would place her. (She would assume the status of her husband, whether it was above or below her own.) By the mid sixteenth century, some girls were permitted to attend grammar school with their brothers, and later, thanks to those protestants who envied the education obtained in nunneries in Europe, private schools were established for those young ladies whose families could afford the expense.
Young girls of the wealthy–like their brothers–were often placed by their families in the household of a friend or acquaintance: there they would learn to read, write, keep accounts, manage a household and estate, make salves and practice surgery. The learning of social skills such as singing and dancing was also important. However, as universities would not admit women, the future for most girls involved marriage, children, and household duties.”²
This difference we see in the play: Lucentio arrives in Padua to continue his studies in the university, he has already been educated, and, being a rich man, he can travel to other cities, see the world and have further education.
Meanwhile, Baptista’s daughter Bianca needs a schoolmaster to teach her languages and music. She (as well as earlier her sister, we suppose) has to be educated at home, and her studies do not go further very general, “womanish” subjects. Anyway, even this was a privilege for a girl at that time. Baptista must have been rich enough to be able to give his daughters education.
But why was it so? Why such a difference? We can find the answer in the understanding of social roles that men and women had. Men were considered to be the cleverest and the most powerful in the family. Men were making decisions and providing for his wife and children. As Katherine herself says it in her final speech of “The Taming of the Shrew”:
Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper,
Thy head, thy sovereign; one that cares for thee,
And for thy maintenance commits his body
To painful labor both by sea and land,
To watch the night in storms, the day in cold,
Whilst thou liest warm at home, secure and safe;
(A , Act 5, Scene 2, lines 146-151. From now on I will use this on-line text as a reference for the quotations)
To perform this difficult task boys, obviously enough, had to receive good education.
As for women, all they needed was practical knowledge of how to manage a household, because this was practically the only sphere of life available to her. Only with the movement of Humanism the situation concerning women’s education was changed. But when the sixteenth century Humanists discussed this topic, they found themselves redefining femininity. They had to decide whether femininity was natural or social, eternal or ephemeral, absolute or relative.
Thomas More, and the Humanists who followed his lead, saw that women’s upbringing, based on the assumption that women were by nature weak in the head, led to situations where their ignorance and frivolity confirmed the belief. Education defined a woman’s sphere, placing the needle in her hand, and the pen or the sword in her brother’s. If learning was for men, a learned woman must be masculine. It is unfeminine to find pleasure in books. The Humanists scoffed at the notion that needlework could improve the mind, or that the daily round of “rouging and hair-dressing”, going to church for the sake of being seen, gossiping, reading romances and associating mainly with the servants could create any idea of the feminine nature which was not synonymous with folly.
However, there were some people who supported the idea of such a limited education and even found it the most appropriate and natural. Thus Nathaniel Hawthorne described the way in which the outcast Hester Prynne in “The Scarlet Letter” earned her living: “It was the art, – then, as now, almost the only one within a woman’s grasp – of needlework…Women derive a pleasure, incomprehensible to the other sex, from the delicate toil of the needle.” Juliet Dusinberre in her book “Shakepeare and the Nature of Women” would criticize him strongly saying that “Hawthorne perceived no relation between an extraordinary feminine delight in sewing and the social fact that there was nothing else to do. When More and Erasmus attacked the needle as the sceptre of the feminine empire, they suggested for women other pleasures as well as other work. The Humanists believed that women might escape from the traditional male circumference of the feminine without becoming masculine. More set the stage on which Shakespeare and his fellows asked questions about the nature of women which could not be answered by society’s definition of femininity.” (1 , pages 230-231)
Posted in Shakespeare in Performance | No Comments »